EPA overreaches in proposed lead rule extension


EPA has now gone way off the deep end and is proposing to extend the lead paint renovation rule to commercial and government buildings and will rely heavily on computer modeling rather than actual data.

It made sense when the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency banned lead in many consumer products in order to protect children. The agency banned lead in gasoline, in paint and in plumbing products that convey drinking water. This all started in the ‘70s. When lead was found to be harmful, lead was first banned in gasoline in 1973 and then in other products. Lead paint was banned in 1978. Lead was banned in 50:50 tin/lead solder used for potable water pipe in the late 1980s and finally in brass plumbing fittings this year.

Because this has been going on for so long, the results have been measurable. The amount of lead in the bloodstreams of children has fallen to negligible levels. Nevertheless, lead paint in dwellings built (and painted) before 1978 still posed a problem, so it was not beyond the pale when EPA proposed rules to protect children when walls in such structures were knocked down or drilled through during renovations. The rules also applied to daycare centers and schools, a.k.a. Child-Occupied Facilities. Since EPA has an acronym for everything, it refers to them as COFs.

EPA has now gone way off the deep end and is proposing to extend the lead paint renovation rule to commercial and government buildings.

EPA is seeking public comment on the “Framework for Identifying and Evaluating Lead-Based Paint Hazards from Renovation, Repair, and Painting Activities in Public and Commercial Buildings.” (Of course, there’s an acronym, P&CB.) The Framework describes an approach for identifying and evaluating potential hazards created by renovations of public and commercial buildings.

EPA maintains that the authority granted to it under the Toxic Substances Control Act will allow it to extend the rule to commercial and government buildings in the same way that it gave the agency the authority to ban lead paint. It claims that Section 402(c)(3) of TCSA directs EPA to revise its lead abatement activities to apply to renovation or remodeling activities in public and commercial buildings constructed before 1978.

In its Framework Document, EPA gets speculative: “The lead dust created during P&CB renovations can move downwind to surrounding COFs, residences and P&CBs. This dust can penetrate these buildings via air infiltration. In addition, dust can deposit on the ground or hard surfaces, leading to elevated lead levels and subsequent track-in of dust, which would contribute to interior dust levels.”

And here’s where it gets really murky. EPA is proposing to “measure” the efficacy of this rule in protecting children from lead hazards not based on actual data, but based on computer modeling.

I’m having a hard time getting anyone to comment on this proposed rule on the record because apparently they’ve been rendered speechless. Or maybe just dumbfounded about how convoluted this proposal is.

In one of its newsletters, the Plumbing-Heating-Cooling Contractors – National Association states that PHCC, “continues to be concerned that — without considering real data — the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency may publish a ‘one size fits all’ lead paint rule for public and commercial buildings. To make sure real-life feedback from renovation contractors is considered, PHCC will meet … with the Lead Paint Coalition to continue an assessment of a lead paint rule framework document recently released by the EPA.

Rather than submitting comments on its own by EPA’s June 30 deadline, PHCC joined the Commercial Properties Coalition in stating, “The Framework (proposed rule) would benefit from fuller development of its methodology and inputs, independent peer review, and EPA’s consideration of technical reviewers’ comments before soliciting public comment or proceeding to rely on this approach.”

If you want to get into the arcane details of regulation, you can read the Commercial Properties Coalition’s 34 pages of formal comments here.

The Framework document also establishes an accelerated, consolidated process that the coalition believes skips a few required steps, the Coalition said. For example, the EPA proposes combining the hazard identification and regulation process into one proceeding, which the coalition describes as “misguided.” (In comparison, the residential lead paint rule was established seven years after the EPA conducted a rulemaking to develop a hazard identification standard.) The coalition letter states that the EPA does not have the authority to create shortcuts or avoid rulemakings, studies and a chronology that Congress has established.

The industry group’s response agrees with EPA’s conclusion that “One Size Fits All” approach is not appropriate for P&CB because they “vary greatly” in terms of their sizes, shapes, configurations, uses, occupancies and cleaning frequencies. These differences create an increased need to first identify which specific settings create a hazard and actually fall within EPA’s regulatory authority rather than combining the identification and regulation processes.

The coalition also states that the Framework’s technical aspects are novel, not fully developed, and open to question.  The group advised that EPA should proceed by identifying whether specific P&CB lead paint hazards exist. There’s a novel idea — find out if specific lead paint hazards exist before you regulate.

PHCC has long argued that public policy must be the direct result of scientific research and data — not computer modeling — to assess health risks of lead paint dust exposure. We here at CONTRACTOR agree with that.

Another veteran government affairs professional was fatalistic. You can’t beat these guys, he told me; if you sue EPA, you’re not going to win, so don’t bother. The two things an association can do, he said, is to train its members well to mitigate lead dust during renovations and draft iron-clad, cover-your-butt model contract language they can use.

Let’s hope that in the coming months that EPA reconsiders this regulatory misadventure and either shelves it entirely or converts it to best practices guidelines.

Every so often I say something worth hearing on Twitter @bobmader

Discuss this Blog Entry 21

on Jul 27, 2014


on Sep 4, 2014

Obat Kanker Payudara
Apa anda mengerti pengertian dari dari Sakit Kanker Payudara? Kanker payudara ialah kanker yang terjadi pada bagian payudara wanita, atau keganasan yang bermula sel-sel dalam payudara wanita. Kanker payudara kebiasaan dialami oleh kaum perempuan, tetapi ada beberapa kasussakit payudara terjangkit juga pada para laki-laki. Hanya saja pembuktian tertuju bahwa 80 persenpenyakit payudara dialami lebih kebanyakan pada para perempuan. Kanker payudara menjadi ancaman tersendiri bagi kesehatan kaum wanita. pada umumnya sakit kanker payudara diberi tanda dengan adanya gumpalan di bagian payudara. Tapi kita wajib berjaga-jaga oleh karena jenis kanker juga bisa mengganas tanpa menunjukkan adanya berbentuk benjolan.
Menurut Dr. Alfiah Amiruddin, MD, MS, terdapat 20 jenis penyakit kanker payudara yang menunjukkan ditandai dengan bentuk benjolan. Dengan demikian tak sejenis sakit kanker payudara lainnya, jenis penyakit menunjukkan adanya bentuk benjol. Gejala diawali yang ditunjukkan semacam radang seperti bekas gigitan serangga.Jenis Kanker ini tergolong jenis yang paling ganas. obat herbal kanker payudara alami

on Feb 8, 2016

OST Anime MP3 | Free Download Ost Anime

on Nov 13, 2014

Gagal Ginjal Sehabis Konsumsi Obat Sakit Jantung
Nama saya Bpk.Sigit Yuwono, kelahiran di Surabaya lima puluh delapan tahun lalu tidak disangka saya menderita penyakit gagal ginjal. "beliau bekerja di perusahaan perambah hutan yang berlokasi di bagian Papua. Karna medan dan pekerjaan yang cukup berat, tenaga secara fisik harus dibutuhkan, namun sekuat-kuatnya fisik manusia tidak akan mungkin bertahan selamanya, sewaktu-waktu nanti mungkin akan rapuh juga," cerita bapak dari 4 anak ini. Semua yang dikatakannya tentang kekuatan tubuh benar terjadi, dia mengalami masalah jantungnya pada saat mengangkat sepeda motornya yang terjerembab didalam lumpur dalam hutan Irian Jaya. obat penyakit gagal ginjal
obat herbal flek paru alami
obat radang paru paru

on Jul 27, 2014

The Environment protection agency is doing a great job with banning the lead in many products for the protection of the children.I was looking to do my assignment helps to complete your homework from the high qualified expert writers.

on Aug 4, 2014

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

independence day wallpapers
independence day images|
independence day quotes||
independence day sms|
independence day wishes|
independence day poems|
independence day message|
independence day |
Happy independence day images|
Happy independence day quotes|
independence day speech|
independence day greetings|

on Aug 1, 2014

The two things an association can do

on Aug 15, 2014

Superb blog you have a good writing skill the information you shared here is really good work.
Assignment Help Australia
Thesis Help

on Nov 20, 2014
on Nov 21, 2014

Dengan menggunakan obat Penyakit kutil kelamin herbal untuk wanita yang terbuat dari herbal insyaalah dalam 3-5 hari kutil rontok sampai ke akar akarnya serta tidak tumbuh lagi. Kutil kelamin pada wanita biasanya Tumbuh di sekitar vagina bagian luar kadang juga pada sekitar lobang alat vital Apa Obatnya tanpa harus operasi karena saya sangat bingung untuk solusinya. sebelumnya akan saya jelaskan sedikit mengenai apa itu kutil kelamin Ternyata, kutil tak hanya tumbuh di permukaan tubuh saja, bagian organ dalam manusia pun dapat ditumbuhi oleh kutil, misalnya di dalam organ intim yang memiliki permukaan lembab. obat kutil kelamin pria | obat kutil kelamin wanita paling ampuh penyebab kutil di kelamin pria | penyebab kutil kelamin pada wanita

on Dec 4, 2014

Ginsneg RH2 terbuat dari ekstrak ginseng merah yang sangat langka keberadaannya. Sangat ampuh untuk mengatasi berbagai macam penyakit kanker, terutama penyakit kanker payudara. obat herbal kanker payudara

on May 5, 2015

Great article writing thanks . Nice information

on Nov 3, 2015

nice post

on Feb 20, 2017

I liked his discussion and hopefully a lot of other people who may read this article.

on Mar 28, 2017

Get your finance homework help for assignments and projects from top finance writers. We are number 1 academic writing service when it comes to financial management assignments.

on Mar 28, 2017

Get your finance homework help for assignments and projects from top finance writers. We are number 1 academic writing service when it comes to financial management assignments.

on Mar 28, 2017

Get your finance homework help for assignments and projects from top finance writers. We are number 1 academic writing service when it comes to financial management assignments.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's As I See It?

Robert Mader's Blog


Robert Mader

Bob Mader is the editor of CONTRACTOR magazine, Green Mechanical Contractor magazine, and Radiant Living magazine. He has been writing about plumbing, mechanical, green building and HVACR topics for...
Blog Archive

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×